Legal disclaimer: This article is based solely on documents released in the federal EFTA (Electronic Filing and Text Archive) production, made public through litigation, supplemented by the archive's entity index. All facts are drawn from those documents. This article does not assert guilt, wrongdoing, or criminal conduct on the part of any individual. Language such as "documents indicate," "records show," and "alleged" reflects the evidentiary basis and does not constitute a legal conclusion. Minors are not identified in this reporting.
Barnaby Marsh appears in more than 2,270 records in the InvArchives repository under the archive's entity index. Documents recovered from the production — running from a September 2009 email to a January 2018 exchange — show Marsh, who held senior grantmaking roles at the John Templeton Foundation, maintaining a personal correspondence with Jeffrey Epstein for nearly a decade, appearing on Epstein's Harvard and MIT itineraries, and being addressed directly by Epstein and his staff on matters involving a $1.5 million Templeton Foundation research grant.
Get the full documents delivered to your inbox — subscribe to the InvArchives newsletter.
Two letters in the archive identify Marsh's role in full: "Barnaby Marsh, D.Phil., Executive Vice President, Strategic Initiatives and Managing Director, Philanthropic Leadership Network, John Templeton Foundation," addressed at the foundation's West Conshohocken, Pennsylvania office (Enhanced Education letter to Barnaby Marsh, D.Phil.; Enhanced Education letter to Dr. Marsh). The Templeton Foundation is one of the world's largest funders of academic research at the intersection of science, philosophy and religion.
The earliest record of contact is a September 2009 email from Epstein's jeevacation@gmail.com account to Marsh (From: Jeffrey Epstein, September 26, 2009). Over the following years, the correspondence shows a pattern that recurs dozens of times: informal notes arranging calls, lunches and visits, often relayed through Epstein's scheduler Lesley Groff. In March 2012, Groff forwarded word that "Barnaby Marsh will be able to join the meeting on Sunday at 1pm" (Barnaby Marsh will be able to join the meeting on Sunday). In July 2012 an "alarm — reminder" was set for "Barnaby Marsh to be in NY July 13th" (Alarm - reminder: Barnaby Marsh to be in NY), and in December 2012 Groff relayed that Marsh had accepted a lunch invitation to discuss a visit alongside Bard College president Leon Botstein (Barnaby Marsh has replied to the email re Leon Botstein and lunch). Other threads show Epstein's staff scheduling repeated dinners and lunches with Marsh at Epstein's Manhattan townhouse through 2012 (Re: Jeffrey Epstein — dinner scheduling, May 2012; Re: Jeffrey Epstein — lunch scheduling, December 2012).
A detailed itinerary for "Jeffrey's Harvard Trip: April 21–23, 2014" places Marsh at a meeting alongside Epstein at the MIT Media Lab: "3–5:00pm Meeting at the Media Lab at MIT w/Joi Ito, Barnaby Marsh, Martin Nowak, Kevin Slavin," followed over the next two days by appointments with Harvard psychologist Dan Gilbert, astronomer Dimitar Sasselov, geneticist George Church, physicist Andrew Strominger, psychologist Jerome Kagan and anthropologist Daniel Lieberman (Jeffrey's Harvard Trip itinerary, April 2014). Marsh also corresponded and met directly with Media Lab director Joi Ito: a April 2014 email confirms "we're meeting at 3PM tomorrow ... in my office" (Joi Ito: meeting tomorrow), and in September 2014 Ito wrote to Epstein and Marsh asking "can we set up a call between Jeffrey, Barnaby and me?" (Call — Joi Ito to Epstein and Marsh).
In November 2015, Harvard mathematical biologist Martin Nowak — director of Harvard's Program for Evolutionary Dynamics — asked Epstein directly to sign a letter to Marsh supporting a $1.5 million grant application to the Templeton Foundation. Nowak's email to Epstein reads: "this is the proposed text for a letter from jeffrey sent directly to Barnaby Marsh[.] the john Templeton Foundation is considering awarding me a grant for 1.5M[.] they need confirmation from the donor (Jeffrey) that I already have matching funds" (Fwd: draft letter to Barnaby Marsh re Nowak's Templeton grant). The draft letter, addressed "Dear Barnaby" and signed "Jeffrey E. Epstein, New York, NY," represents that Epstein had "established this gift to the Program for Evolutionary Dynamics" in 2003 and that Harvard had already secured $1,500,328 in matching funds "budgeted for this project" for 2016–2018.
An identical letter in the record is instead signed by Darren Indyke as "Vice President" of Epstein's nonprofit, Enhanced Education, on Epstein's Virgin Islands letterhead, addressed the same way to "Dear Barnaby" and "Dear Dr. Marsh" in two separate copies dated three days apart (Enhanced Education letter to Barnaby Marsh, D.Phil., November 24, 2015; Enhanced Education letter to Dr. Marsh, December 2, 2015). Richard Kahn, Epstein's financial manager, forwarded the final version to Epstein on November 25, 2015, writing "i sent letter to Barnaby yesterday and he approved [the] language[,] please advise if ok for darren to sign and send back to barnaby," to which Marsh had replied the day before, "looks good — thanks" (Fwd: Matching Funds Letter).
Marsh's role extended beyond Nowak's grant. A September 2014 draft proposal titled "Finding Genius in an Antidisciplinary World," prepared by the Media Lab for submission to the Templeton Foundation, sought $1.725 million to fund ten $100,000 prizes for unconventional researchers, to be administered by Joi Ito. The proposal states that it "resulted, in part, from conversations that Joi Ito has had with Barnaby Marsh and Ayako Fukui at the foundation," and discloses that its initial $300,000 in "supplemental" startup funding came from "an anonymous $500,000 gift" from Leon Black, the private-equity billionaire and Apollo Global co-founder (Draft Templeton Proposal: Finding Genius in an Antidisciplinary World). The document cited here does not describe any direct contact between Black and Epstein. Ito forwarded an updated draft of the proposal directly to Epstein and Marsh together in September 2014 (Fwd: Templeton Media Lab proposal, draft update). Separately, in March 2016, Nowak emailed Epstein and Marsh together to pitch a new "institute ... for math of life, biological computing, the next step of evolution beyond language" (Nowak to Epstein and Marsh: institute proposal).
Beyond grant business, the correspondence documents a personal relationship. Emails from late December 2014 through early January 2015, subject-lined "USVI," show Marsh and Epstein arranging repeated meetings in the U.S. Virgin Islands over the New Year's holiday, coordinating pickups by helicopter and boat; Marsh wrote on January 3, 2015, "Nice to see you today and THANKS for the Island hospitality," and on January 8, "It was fabulous and fun to see you here" (Re: USVI, January 2015; Re: USVI, January 2015 (duplicate thread)).
In May 2015, three days after John M. "Jack" Templeton Jr. — the foundation's chairman — died on May 18, 2015, Epstein wrote to Marsh asking "does jacks death have a big impact on your work?" and separately invited him to a Harvard visit: "going to harvard on thurs, chomsky, if you would like to come along" (Re: Zurich/ETH and Jack Templeton's death; Re: Harvard trip invitation). In 2017, Groff twice pressed Marsh on Epstein's behalf to arrange an introduction to a contact identified in the emails only as "James Simon," first in March and again in a May follow-up reminder to Epstein: "Reminder you wanted Barnaby Marsh to introduce you to James Simon. Should I follow up with Barnaby on this again?" (Reminder: Barnaby Marsh/James Simon; Re: Jeffrey Epstein — any word from James Simon?). The documents in the archive do not identify this contact further.
The documents place Marsh — through his Templeton Foundation role — inside the same funding and social circuit as Joi Ito, Martin Nowak and Leon Botstein, each of whom appears alongside Marsh in the itineraries, correspondence and grant paperwork cited above. The record shows Marsh corresponding with Epstein for nearly a decade, appearing on his Harvard itinerary, being addressed in matching-funds paperwork for a Templeton grant, and visiting him socially in the Virgin Islands. None of the documents cited here shows Marsh receiving money from Epstein, and none describes conduct by Marsh beyond routine grantmaking correspondence and personal socializing.
Get the full documents delivered to your inbox — subscribe to the InvArchives newsletter.
Cited Documents
Share this investigation